CONVEX
Scenario × Asset Analysis

What Happens to Leading Index for US When Commercial & Industrial Loans Contract?

Commercial and Industrial (C&I) loan contraction signals bank credit retrenchment. What happens to growth, jobs, and investment when business credit shrinks?

Leading Index for US
1.72
as of Feb 1, 2020
Full chart →
Trigger: C&I Loans (All Banks)
$3B
Condition: year-over-year growth turns negative
Monitor trigger →

How Leading Index for US Responds

LEI components capturing credit (SLOOS, spreads) typically turn negative before C&I loans. The two together (LEI negative and C&I contracting) is the highest-confidence recession signal.

Scenario Background

Commercial and Industrial (C&I) loans are bank lending to businesses for working capital, inventory, and investment. Year-over-year contraction in C&I loans signals that banks are reducing credit to the business sector, typically because banks are tightening standards, demand is falling, or borrowers are deleveraging.

Read full scenario analysis →

Historical Context

C&I loans contracted year-over-year during 1991 (-5% trough), 2002-2004 (-8% trough, extended contraction), 2009-2010 (-20% trough, the deepest post-war contraction), and 2020-2021 (-15% trough, driven by PPP dynamics and COVID). Each contraction preceded or coincided with recession and substantial job losses. The 2009 contraction saw non-residential construction spending fall 25% and business equipment investment fall 20% as C&I credit evaporated. The 2020 contraction was partly technical (PPP ...

What to Watch For

  • DRTSCILM showing net tightening percentage above 40%
  • SBA 7(a) loan volumes declining year-over-year
  • NFIB Small Business Optimism Index below 90
  • Commercial and Industrial loan applications declining
  • Bank earnings showing loan-loss provision increases

Other Assets When Commercial & Industrial Loans Contract

Get scenario analysis and Leading Index for US alerts delivered to your inbox.